MG Comet EV Executive vs Tata Punch.ev Smart 30
Reviewed by the EVz Editorial Team · July 2026 · how we verify
On running cost, the MG Comet EV Executive saves more versus petrol (about ₹82,733/year). On-road price is a Delhi estimate; pick your city on each model's page. Full side-by-side below.
Pick the MG Comet EV Executive for a lower price and a lower on-road cost; choose the Tata Punch.ev Smart 30 for more power and a bigger battery. Leads 3-2 of 9 tracked specs.
| Head-to-head 9 specs compared |  MG Comet EV Executive ₹7,79,800 Wins 3 of 9 |  Tata Punch.ev Smart 30 ₹9,69,000 Wins 2 of 9 |
|---|---|---|
| Price (ex-showroom) | ₹7,79,800Best | ₹9,69,000 |
| On-road (Delhi, est.) | ₹8,07,093Best | ₹10,02,915 |
| Range | 230 km ARAI | 365 km ARAI |
| Battery | 17.4 kWh | 30 kWhBest |
| Charging | 0-100% in ~7h on 3.3kW AC; no DC fast charging (Type 2 AC only) | 20-80% in ~26 min on 65 kW DC fast charger; AC home charging via 7.2 kW wallbox |
| Motor | 31 kW | 65 kWBest |
| Top speed | - | - |
| Est. annual saving vs petrol | ₹82,733 | ₹82,733 |
| Est. insurance (year 1) | ₹27,293Best | ₹33,915 |
"real" = independently tested real-world range; "ARAI" = manufacturer's certified claim. Bars scale each row to the leader; "Best" marks the stronger value. On-road and insurance are Delhi estimates, not quotes.
Full details: MG Comet EV Executive · Tata Punch.ev Smart 30
FAQ
Which is better, the MG Comet EV Executive or the Tata Punch.ev Smart 30?
Pick the MG Comet EV Executive for a lower price and a lower on-road cost; choose the Tata Punch.ev Smart 30 for more power and a bigger battery.
Is the MG Comet EV Executive or the Tata Punch.ev Smart 30 cheaper?
The MG Comet EV Executive is cheaper ex-showroom: ₹7,79,800 versus ₹9,69,000. On-road in Delhi, the MG Comet EV Executive is cheaper (₹8,07,093).
Which has more real-world range, the MG Comet EV Executive or the Tata Punch.ev Smart 30?
A verified real-world range is not yet published for both models; each model's page shows what is available.